ColorPal palettes improved!

In my last post on the subject, I introduced ColorPal, my HTML5 color palette generation tool. It didn’t perform well with certain types of images, so I fixed it. :)


ColorPal logo

Color palettes will now match the image even better. Especially for images with infrequent but important colors. Here’s a comparison of the old and new methods, on an image that is mostly black:

comparison of palettes generated with median and
mean

You can see that with the old method, the black pixels definitely took over the palette.

Try it with your own images!

For some images, this change won’t affect palettes at all. But for images with low-population, high-importance colors, like the one above, palettes will look much better!

Technical discussion below.

Why the ‘median’ in median-cut?

Median Cut is an algorithm typically used to reduce the number of colors in an image.

16 million colors versus 16 colors

The steps to perform median cut are fairly straightforward:

  1. Find the smallest box which contains all the colors.
  2. Sort the enclosed colors along the longest axis of the box.
  3. Split the box into two regions at median of the sorted list.
  4. Repeat the above process until the original color space has been divided into N regions where N is the number of colors you want.

Not too bad, right? The question remains, though, why median?

Mean, median, and mode all attempt to measure the location of a probability distribution. Worded more intuitively… they try to find the center of a set of numbers. They just employ different definitions of “center”.

mean, median, and mode graphed (Thanks Wikipedia)

As you can see clearly in the dashed data set, the mean tends to follow the tail. In other words, mean is useful when outliers are important. When generating a color palette, outliers are essential. Outliers may be the small streak of color in an otherwise drab sky, or a small red rose in the middle of a green field.

The goal of median cut is not to generate a color palette. It’s to efficiently reduce the number of colors in an image. Since my goal with ColorPal is to find good-lookin’ colors, I’ve modified the algorithm to split boxes at the mean instead of the median. Mean splits boxes closer to the outliers, which keeps low-population colors nicely segregated from the high-population colors.

Thus step 3 becomes:

  • Split the box into two regions at the mean of the sorted list.

The result? Mean Cut! Also: awesome color palettes.

Interesting side-note on color distributions

Interestingly, photographs of nature tend to have nice, close-to-normal color distributions. A “normal distribution” is a formal term for a “bell curve”.

Check out the red, green, and blue distributions for a photograph of a forest.

Forest red   pixel distribution Forest green pixel distribution Forest blue  pixel distribution

For comparison, here are the distributions for a shot of NYC.

City   red   pixel distribution City   green pixel distribution City   blue  pixel distribution

What’s next for ColorPal? Color spaces.

Mean-cut improves ColorPal dramatically for some images, but it’s still not perfect. Perfection probably won’t be attainable, but there are still many ways to improve.

My next test will be converting to a color space other than RGB.

HSL is common, and the RGB/HSL conversion formulas are in my very old JSImage project. It may not turn out well, though, as the concept of “widest box” loses most of its meaning when each axis is a completely different unit of measure. Although, in a way, I suppose RGB has a similar problem. Red, Green, and Blue could be thought of as unrelated units. I’ll try it out and see how it goes. I wonder if my old JavaScript RGB/HSL code has rotted away yet…

Most likely, I’ll skip HSL and try one of the Lab color spaces first, since they are not composed linear values like RGB and HSL. Instead, Lab color spaces use non-linear scales that closely match human perception of color. Perfect for my purposes. How fortuitious for me that CIE invented it way back in 1931.

There are three “Lab” color spaces: XYZ, Hunter-Lab, and CIELAB. XYZ will be first to the plate, since the RGB/XYZ formulas are the simplest. Let me take this opportune moment to plug EasyRGB.com.

Lend a hand

As I’ve mentioned before, ColorPal is in an early stage of development. It needs testing in multiple browsers, and I’m very interested in hearing people’s feedback. Code development help is welcomed too.

If you try out ColorPal, let me know your thoughts on Twitter.

Here are github repos for ColorPal and median-cut.js.